First bonsai: which one should you really choose if you’ve never had one before?
Every month I receive at least 10 emails that begin more or less like this: “I bought my first bonsai, it’s dying—what do I do?” In 90% of cases, the problem isn’t care. It’s the initial choice. The first bonsai was chosen at random—often at a supermarket, often a cheap Ficus ginseng, often without considering the climate at home. And that bonsai was destined to die before it even left the display. In this article, I’ll explain how to REALLY choose your first bonsai. Not “the 10 easiest”—YOUR bonsai. Because the right species depends on where you live, how much light you have at home, and how much time you can devote to it. Then I’ll tell you which 3 to buy, and which 4 to NEVER buy as your first.
In brief (for those in a hurry)
- The choice of your first bonsai should be based on the local climate and available sunlight, not just the plant’s appearance.
- Ficus retusa is the most suitable species for beginners growing bonsai indoors, thanks to its resistance to environmental fluctuations.
- Most bonsai (maples, pines, and junipers) are outdoor plants that need winter dormancy to survive.
- A realistic budget for a healthy, trained specimen ranges from 50 to 80 euros, avoiding inexpensive plants from mass retailers.
- The essential starter kit includes specialized scissors, balanced fertilizer, and a well-draining substrate such as akadama for future repotting.
The great misunderstanding: indoor or outdoor bonsai?
Most bonsai are outdoor plants, such as maples, pines, and junipers, which need winter dormancy in the cold to complete their biological cycle. Only certain tropical species, such as Ficus retusa and Carmona, tolerate year-round indoor cultivation in temperate climates. If you live in an apartment without a balcony, your choice is limited to these tropical varieties.
We need to dispel a commercial myth right away: the concept of an “indoor bonsai” is often a marketing exaggeration. In nature, no tree grows within four walls. However, some species from equatorial climates cannot tolerate temperatures below 10–12°C and have consequently adapted to living in our heated apartments during winter. If you have a balcony, terrace, or garden, the world of bonsai opens up to hundreds of temperate species that follow the rhythm of the seasons.
Growing a Japanese maple or a pine in the living room is a certain death sentence for the plant. These species need winter cold to enter dormancy; without this rest, their metabolism continues to run until their resources are depleted, leading to sudden drying out in spring. If you have no outdoor space, focus exclusively on Ficus or Zelkova (Chinese elms) kept in cool areas.
Recommended products for you
The 3 questions to ask BEFORE buying
Before buying your first bonsai, you need to analyze three critical factors: your climate zone, your home’s light exposure, and the amount of time you can devote to it each day. These variables determine whether the plant will thrive for decades or become a pile of dry branches within a few weeks.
- Where do you live? If you live in northern Italy, in a continental climate, temperate outdoor species are perfect, but you will need to protect them from severe frost. If you live in Mediterranean southern Italy, almost any species can live outdoors year-round. If you live in a studio apartment in Milan without a balcony, you are obliged to choose a tropical indoor species.
- What kind of space do you have? Light is the bonsai’s fuel. A south- or west-facing window is ideal for a Ficus. If you have a balcony that gets sunlight only in the morning, Chinese elm is an excellent choice. Without intense natural light, no care technique can save your tree.
- How much time can you dedicate to it? A bonsai is not a decorative ornament. It requires daily monitoring of the soil moisture. If you travel often and have no one who can water it, you should choose more resilient species such as Ficus, avoiding delicate varieties such as Serissa or Maple.
Recommended products for you
The 3 Bonsai to Buy as Your First (with a Realistic Rationale)
To get started successfully, I recommend three species that forgive beginners' small mistakes and show great biological resilience. Ficus retusa is the king of indoor bonsai, Chinese elm is the most versatile for those with mixed spaces, while juniper is the perfect choice for anyone who wants to experience the art of bonsai outdoors.
Ficus retusa (or microcarpa)
Ficus retusa is the most indestructible tropical species for beginners. It tolerates dry apartment air well, withstands short periods of drought, and has a vigorous root system that handles repotting well. It is the obvious choice if you do not have a balcony.
- Indicative price: €40 - €75
- Basic care: Bright light, water when the potting soil is dry on the surface, and mist the leaves in winter.
- Typical mistake: Placing it away from the window or above a lit radiator.
Ulmus parvifolia (Chinese Elm)
The Chinese elm is an incredibly forgiving semi-hardy plant. It has small, well-proportioned leaves, grows quickly so you can see the results of your pruning right away, and can live both indoors (in cool areas) and outdoors in mild climates.
- Indicative price: €35 - €60
- Basic care: Keep the soil consistently moist but not waterlogged, provide plenty of light, and fertilize regularly during the growing season.
- Typical mistake: Allowing the soil to dry out completely, causing the leaves to fall immediately.
Juniperus (Juniper)
If you have a garden or sunny balcony, the juniper is the quintessential authentic bonsai. It is a robust conifer that embodies the wabi-sabi style. It must stay outdoors, where it can experience the changing seasons and winter cold.
- Indicative price: €50 - €90
- Basic care: Full sun, perfect drainage, and periodic removal of dry needles from inside the canopy.
- Typical mistake: Bringing it indoors "for beauty" during winter, killing it through lack of oxygen and cold.
| Species | Location | Difficulty | Ideal Climate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ficus retusa | Indoor | Low | Bright apartment |
| Chinese Elm | Mixed | Medium-Low | Balcony / Terrace |
| Juniper | Outdoor | Medium | Sunny garden |
Recommended products for you
The 4 bonsai NOT to buy as your first (even if discounted)
Some plants, while beautiful, are a trap for inexperienced growers. Avoiding these species for your first purchase will save you frustration and money, allowing you to learn the basics with more cooperative varieties that are less susceptible to minor environmental stress.
Commercial ginseng ficus
It is not a true bonsai, but a cutting of Ficus microcarpa grafted onto tuberous roots. The aesthetics are often disproportionate, and the grafts can suddenly dry out if the plant experiences heat stress. It is an industrial product, not a living work of art.
Japanese maple (Acer palmatum)
The maple is the icon of bonsai, but it is extremely delicate. It is sensitive to direct summer sunlight, which scorches the leaves, suffers from excessively hard water, and requires precise watering management. For a beginner, watching the leaves dry out in August can be discouraging.
Pine (Pinus)
Pines require advanced techniques such as 'candle' pruning (pinching new shoots) and manually cleaning the needles. Without years of training, it is easy to prune at the wrong time and permanently compromise the plant's health. It is a milestone, not a starting point.
Serissa foetida (Tree of a Thousand Stars)
The name is poetic, but the plant is temperamental. Serissa drops its leaves at the slightest disturbance, suffers from changes in humidity, and easily attracts pests if conditions are not perfect. Among bonsai growers, it is known as one of the most difficult species to keep stable indoors.
Recommended products for you
Realistic budget: how much to spend on your first bonsai
The price of a bonsai reflects the years of care, pruning, and repotting an expert has already devoted to the plant. Spending too little means buying a specimen that has not yet been established, while a considered investment ensures a plant with a mature root system and a structure that will make learning easier.
The truth is that the €50–80 range is the sweet spot for your first serious bonsai. In this range, you can find 5–8-year-old specimens that are already aesthetically styled and have strong roots that better tolerate minor mistakes caused by inattention. Below €20, you are usually buying only a cutting in a plastic pot, often with poor-quality soil that suffocates the roots.
- €30–60: Young bonsai (2–4 years of training). Excellent for those who want to learn to grow the plant while following its early development.
- €60–120: Fully shaped bonsai (5–8 years old). Recognizable aesthetics, a nicely tapered trunk, and a visible, healthy root base (nebari).
- €150+: Mature bonsai (10+ years). It requires serious commitment and an already solid understanding of maintenance techniques.
Recommended products for you
What to buy ALONGSIDE the bonsai (essential first-month kit)
In addition to the plant, you will need some essential tools for routine maintenance. You do not need a professional set costing hundreds of euros, but some accessories are indispensable for ensuring drainage, nourishment, and proper aeration of your new tree’s canopy.
Materials needed to get started:
- Long-handled bonsai scissors: Essential for precise pruning without damaging nearby branches (Cost: €15–25).
- Balanced liquid fertilizer: Apply every 15 days during the growing season to nourish the limited soil available.
- Akadama (small quantity): Japanese clay soil to keep ready for emergency repotting or top-ups.
- Gravel tray: To maintain ambient humidity without causing the roots to rot in standing water.
- Mister: Essential for indoor tropical species during the winter.
Timing: The kit should be used from the first week for monitoring and feeding.
Warnings: Never use ordinary kitchen scissors, as they crush the wood fibers (cambium), preventing healing.
To complete your green corner and create a meditative atmosphere, you can pair your bonsai with natural design elements such as a Rectangular Stabilized Moss and Lichen Picture or a Cashmere Fragrance Diffuser, which help enhance the sense of well-being in the space where you place the plant.
Recommended products for you
Practical FAQ about your first bonsai
What is the easiest bonsai to care for as a beginner?
Ficus retusa is universally considered the easiest bonsai for beginners, especially when grown in an apartment, thanks to its tolerance of low humidity and indirect light.
Is an indoor or outdoor bonsai better for beginners?
It depends on your space. If you have a balcony, an outdoor bonsai, such as an Elm, is more rewarding and healthier. If you live in an apartment, you are obliged to choose a tropical indoor species.
How much does a serious bonsai for beginners cost?
A proper investment ranges from 50 to 80 euros. This amount ensures a plant with an established structure and a root system capable of withstanding the change of ownership.
Is IKEA's Ficus ginseng a real bonsai?
Technically, no. It is a commercial product made by grafting Ficus branches onto artificially swollen roots. It can be a good beginner's exercise, but it does not have the artistic value or longevity of a bonsai from a specialized nursery.
How much time does a bonsai need each day?
Just 2 minutes a day are enough to check the soil moisture, plus 10 minutes a week for cleaning the leaves or fertilizing. Consistency matters more than the amount of time.
Your first bonsai is like your first dog. You don't choose it based on “which one looks best in the shop window”—you choose it based on who you are, how you live, and what you can offer it. If you choose well, it will accompany you for decades and grow with you. If you choose poorly, it will die within a few weeks and convince you that “bonsai aren't for you.” If you're unsure which species is best suited to your balcony or living room, write to me at info@igiardinidigiulia.it: I'll be happy to help you find your first green companion.
